Our rankings are cleverly generated from the algorithmic analysis of thousands of customer reviews about products, brands, merchant's customer service levels, popularity trends, and more. The rankings reflect our opinion and should be a good starting point for shopping. As an Amazon Associate we may earn from qualifying purchases. We may receive a commission from purchases made through links on our site, which will help us continue to provide you with value.
Mystery Categories
Best Choice Audible 
The Blackout Murders: A Homefront Sleuths Mystery (The Homefront Sleuths Cozy Mystery Series, Book 1) Audible The Blackout Murders: A Homefront Sleuths Mystery (The Homefront Sleuths Cozy Mystery Series, Book 1) 
$30 Electronics Mystery Box Set Whether you're into building, programming, or just exploring, this mystery box is a delightful surprise for anyone interBest Value Audible 
Accidental Magic: Myrtlewood Mysteries, Book 1 
$50 Electronics Mystery Box Set Get ready for a surprise with this $50 Mystery Box Set of Assorted Lucky Dip Random Products. Packed in a box, this collAudible Accidental Magic: Myrtlewood Mysteries, Book 1 Tule Publishing 
Someone Murderous at The Midnight Motel: Female Sleuth Cozy Mysteries (The Accidental Detective Book 5) $50 Electronics Mystery Box Set Bear & King Publishing The Jack Rogan Mysteries Series Boxset: Books 1-3 $50 Mystery Box Set of Assorted Lucky Dip Random Products Bear & King Publishing The Jack Rogan Mysteries Series Boxset: Books 1-3 O'Shea Books The Puzzle People (A Berlin Mystery) $100 ➕ Mystery Box Set of Assorted Lucky Dip Random Products For Family Value of item is reflective of this. Item will arrive in either a box or satchel. Mystery Box/Satchel. The real colour oO'Shea Books The Puzzle People (A Berlin Mystery) $10 Mystery Box Set of Assorted Lucky Dip Random Products Get ready for a surprise with this $10 Mystery Box Set of Assorted Lucky Dip Random Products. Each box contains a varietMurder in Toulouse: A Maggie Newberry Mystery (The Maggie Newberry Mystery Series Book 25) Crazy Fun Rainbow Mystery Squishy Bun Dumpling PINK GLITTER VIRAL With a character family of Squishy Bun, this toy is sure to delight children aged 3-4 years with its interactive and engLume Books Crime, Thriller & Mystery SHADES OF DEATH an absolutely gripping and unputdownable British crime mystery (Gripping British Mysteries) 2026 NeeDoh Easter Golden Egg Hunt Mystery (10 Squishy Surprises!) Toy Gift The NeeDoh Golden Egg Hunt is a fun and interactive Easter decoration from Schylling. This toy is designed for various aLume Books Crime, Thriller & Mystery SHADES OF DEATH an absolutely gripping and unputdownable British crime mystery (Gripping British Mysteries) NeeDoh Easter Golden Egg Hunt Mystery (10 Squishy Surprises!) Toy Gift The NeeDoh Golden Egg Hunt is a fun and interactive Easter decoration from Schylling. This toy is designed for various aH.Y. Hanna Dark, Witch & Creamy: A Cozy Fantasy Paranormal Mystery in an English Village with Cats, Legends and Magic (Bewitched by NeeDoh Easter Golden Egg Hunt Mystery (10 Squishy Surprises!) Toy Gift The NeeDoh Golden Egg Hunt is a fun and interactive Easter decoration from Schylling. This toy is designed for various aVinci Books The Voice Thief: A Dark Mystery Deep in the Hill Country (The Adam Cash mystery series Book 5) NeeDoh Easter Golden Egg Hunt Mystery (10 Squishy Surprises!) Collectibles Gift The NeeDoh Golden Egg Hunt is a fun and interactive Easter decoration from Schylling. This toy is designed for various aVinci Books The Voice Thief: A Dark Mystery Deep in the Hill Country (The Adam Cash mystery series Book 5) $200 Electronics Mystery Box Set Whether you're looking to expand your own collection or searching for that perfect gift, this mystery box promises a delBookouture Don't Let Her Go: An absolutely unputdownable, heart-pounding and twisty mystery and suspense thriller (Detective Billie $69 POKEMON MYSTERY BOX - 1x GRADED CARD + 1x RAW/SEALED PROMO CARD 90% of grades will be on average 9-10. We strive to provide you not only great value, but a fun experience.Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense The Mystery of the Missing Book: A cozy crime mystery set in an English village (The Antique Shop Mysteries Book 1) $25 Electronics Mystery Box Set Whether you're into building, programming, or just exploring, this mystery box is a delightful surprise for anyone interJoffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense The Mystery of the Missing Book: A cozy crime mystery set in an English village (The Antique Shop Mysteries Book 1) $100 Electronics Mystery Box Set Whether you're a fan of intricate builds or seeking a blend of functionality and style, this set promises a selection ofSecrets at Saltwick: A Midlife Witch Cozy Mystery (The Moonhaven Mysteries Book 3) Secrets at Saltwick: A Midlife Witch Cozy Mystery (The Moonhaven Mysteries Book 3) McChristieBooks.com A Midsummer Night's Murder (A Jack Dunn & Martha Healey Mystery Book 2) McChristieBooks.com A Midsummer Night's Murder (A Jack Dunn & Martha Healey Mystery Book 2) Vinci Books Changing Fortunes: A gripping Southern mystery series of family secrets, danger, and redemption (Savannah Mystery Series Vinci Books Changing Fortunes: A gripping Southern mystery series of family secrets, danger, and redemption (Savannah Mystery Series Bad Day for Justice: A Courtroom Drama Legal Mystery (Warren & Carmichael Legal Thrillers Book 2) Bad Day for Justice: A Courtroom Drama Legal Mystery (Warren & Carmichael Legal Thrillers Book 2) Ava Strong First Kill (A Layla Caine Mystery Book 1) The Book Folks Murder in the New Forest: A Scottish detective tackles a very English crime (The DI Callum MacLean mysteries Book 1) The Book Folks Murder in the New Forest: A Scottish detective tackles a very English crime (The DI Callum MacLean mysteries Book 1) Bookouture Silenced Girls: An absolutely addictive mystery thriller (Agent Tori Hunter Book 1) MURDER UNDER THE MISTLETOE: A Snowfall Sleuth Mystery (The Snowfall Sleuth Mysteries Book 1) MURDER UNDER THE MISTLETOE: A Snowfall Sleuth Mystery (The Snowfall Sleuth Mysteries Book 1) Green Press/Eva Pohler French Quarter Clues (The Mystery House Series Book 3) Death by the River: A Maggie Crow Mystery Death by the River: A Maggie Crow Mystery The Body at Dead Letter House: A Dead Letter House Cozy Mystery (Dead Letter House Mysteries Book 1) The Body at Dead Letter House: A Dead Letter House Cozy Mystery (Dead Letter House Mysteries Book 1) Audible Murder in the Crypt: A Redmond and Haze Mystery, Book 1 Audible Murder in the Crypt: A Redmond and Haze Mystery, Book 1 Audible An Aura of Mystery: Ellie McEwan Mysteries, Book 1 Audible An Aura of Mystery: Ellie McEwan Mysteries, Book 1 Hollis Thatcher Press, LTD. Springtime is for MURDER (Killer Cozy Mystery Boxed Set) Hollis Thatcher Press, LTD. Springtime is for MURDER (Killer Cozy Mystery Boxed Set) A Steep Introduction to Murder: A Cozy Paranormal Witch Mystery with Tea Magic (Steeped in Magic Book 1) A Steep Introduction to Murder: A Cozy Paranormal Witch Mystery with Tea Magic (Steeped in Magic Book 1) Cheryl Phipps Witchy Awakening: A Paranormal Cozy Mystery (Midlife Potions Book 1) Empress Books Mystic Pieces: a small town paranormal cozy mystery with a reluctant sleuth (Shady Grove Psychic Mystery Book 1) Grapevine (06th October, 2025) The Seven Dials Mystery Fiona Grace Aged for Murder (A Tuscan Vineyard Cozy Mystery Book 1) Audible The Silence at Mystery Bay: A Thomas Austin Crime Thriller, Book 8 Audible The Silence at Mystery Bay: A Thomas Austin Crime Thriller, Book 8 ASA Bowen River (A Bec Whitfield Mystery Book 1) Bookouture A Body on the Doorstep: A completely gripping historical cozy murder mystery (London Ladies' Murder Club Book 1) Cedar Lane Villainy in Vienna: A Fiona Figg Mystery (Fiona Figg Mysteries Book 3) Cedar Lane Villainy in Vienna: A Fiona Figg Mystery (Fiona Figg Mysteries Book 3) SquarePlus Publishing Something Borrowed, Something Blue: A Cozy Mystery with Cats, Summer Secrets, and a Seaside Wedding (Morning Star Cat Sh SquarePlus Publishing Something Borrowed, Something Blue: A Cozy Mystery with Cats, Summer Secrets, and a Seaside Wedding (Morning Star Cat Sh The Timber Lodge Murder: A Southern Cabin Retreat Cozy Mystery (Garnet Run Sewing Circle Mysteries Book 4) The Timber Lodge Murder: A Southern Cabin Retreat Cozy Mystery (Garnet Run Sewing Circle Mysteries Book 4) Bitter Orange at Marrowfen Market : A Magical Village Cozy Mystery (The Moon Jar Witch Mysteries Book 1) Bitter Orange at Marrowfen Market : A Magical Village Cozy Mystery (The Moon Jar Witch Mysteries Book 1) CCS Publishing Baked Justice: A Small Town Bakery Cozy Mystery (Eliza Crumbles Mysteries Book 1) CCS Publishing Baked Justice: A Small Town Bakery Cozy Mystery (Eliza Crumbles Mysteries Book 1) Cashmere Conspiracy (A Hazel Stitchworth Cozy Mystery—Book 1) Fiona Grace Thistlewood Manor: Murder at the Hedgerow (An Eliza Montagu Cozy Mystery Book 1) Jana DeLeon Louisiana Longshot (A Miss Fortune Mystery, Book 1) A Fatal Rendezvous in Mayfair: A Gothic Murder Mystery (London Ladies in Peril Mystery series Book 1) Romantika Publishing LLC Her Dark Silence: Small Town Murder Mystery Romance Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense THE HOUSE OF MYSTERY an addictive crime thriller full of twists (Ellie McEwan Book 3) Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense THE HOUSE OF MYSTERY an addictive crime thriller full of twists (Ellie McEwan Book 3) Byrd Books, LLC Girl Hidden: A Detective Kaitlyn Carr Novella (A Detective Kaitlyn Carr Mystery) Lynda McDaniel Books A Life for a Life: A Mystery Novel (Appalachian Mountain Mysteries Book 1) Bookmarked for Murder: A Small Town Library and Bookshop Cozy Mystery Series (Books and Death Mystery Series Book 1) Bookmarked for Murder: A Small Town Library and Bookshop Cozy Mystery Series (Books and Death Mystery Series Book 1) The Pie Plot Mystery : Festival Poison Mysteries (Sweet Whisk Mysteries Book 1) The Pie Plot Mystery : Festival Poison Mysteries (Sweet Whisk Mysteries Book 1) Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense Murder Most Bookish: A gripping cozy English crime mystery full of twists (The Chiltern Hills Mysteries Book 1) Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense Murder Most Bookish: A gripping cozy English crime mystery full of twists (The Chiltern Hills Mysteries Book 1) Barkside of the Moon Press Sense and Scent Ability (A Nora Black Midlife Psychic Mystery Book 1) Murder, Lumber, and Other Means to Civic Improvement: A Cozy Gilded Age Mystery of Love and Murder (Gilded Age: Fortunes Murder, Lumber, and Other Means to Civic Improvement: A Cozy Gilded Age Mystery of Love and Murder (Gilded Age: Fortunes Murder on the Candlelight Tour: A Holiday Homes Tour Cozy Mystery with Hidden Stairwells and Deadly Inspections (The Pro Murder on the Candlelight Tour: A Holiday Homes Tour Cozy Mystery with Hidden Stairwells and Deadly Inspections (The Pro Kathryn Meyer Griffith Scraps of Paper (Spookie Town Murder Mysteries Book 1) Murder in the Print Room: An Ink & Tide Cozy Mystery (The Ink & Tide Mysteries Book 1) Murder in the Print Room: An Ink & Tide Cozy Mystery (The Ink & Tide Mysteries Book 1) Queen Bee: A Cloverfield Cottage Mystery (THE CLOVERFIELD COTTAGE MYSTERIES Book 3) Queen Bee: A Cloverfield Cottage Mystery (THE CLOVERFIELD COTTAGE MYSTERIES Book 3) Joffe Book crime thriller, mystery and suspense Joffe Books Murder Mystery & Suspense Short Story Collection Volume 2 (Joffe Books Mystery and Thriller short stories) Elizabeth Spann Craig Checked Out (The Village Library Mysteries Book 1) The Book Folks crime thrillers, A Joffe Books company THE WHISKEY BAR MYSTERY a gripping mystery on the west coast of Ireland (The Mayo Mysteries Book 3) The Book Folks crime thrillers, A Joffe Books company THE WHISKEY BAR MYSTERY a gripping mystery on the west coast of Ireland (The Mayo Mysteries Book 3) Bookouture The Next Girl: A gripping crime thriller with a heart-stopping twist (Detective Gina Harte Book 1) The Garden Wall Murder: A Small-Town Coastal Cozy Mystery with a Rescue Dog (The Widow’s Walk Cottage Mysteries Book 1) The Garden Wall Murder: A Small-Town Coastal Cozy Mystery with a Rescue Dog (The Widow’s Walk Cottage Mysteries Book 1) Anna de Wahl, Self-Published The Mysterious Guest: Cedar Harbor Cozy Mysteries Jubilee Publishing Murder On The Brazos: A Clean Private Investigator Mystery (A Fen Maguire Mystery Book 2) Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense DEATH IN KING’S LYNN: A chilling British crime mystery (The Norfolk Coast Murders Book 2) Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense DEATH IN KING’S LYNN: A chilling British crime mystery (The Norfolk Coast Murders Book 2) Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense MURDER ON THE NORFOLK BROADS a gripping British crime mystery (Detective Geldard Mysteries Book 1)